Why I don’t trust that Facebook will keep your child’s information private

Posted by reyjunco on June 14, 2012 in Commentary |

Child Surfing Facebook - Facebook, Children, and PrivacyLast week, I wrote an opinion piece for NBCLatino entitled Don’t trust Facebook with your children in response to Facebook’s announcement that they are considering allowing children younger than 13 to join the site. In that post, I discussed four reasons why you would want to be wary of allowing your children under 13 to join Facebook. Due to space limitations, I didn’t include a fifth that I wanted to elaborate on here:

Privacy: Time and time again, Facebook has been notorious for tricking users into sharing more of their personal information. And yes, I mean tricking and no, I’m not being overly dramatic here as I’ll point out below. Since the Internet has a short memory, let’s briefly review some of these issues:

  • Beacon: In 2007, Facebook launched a system named Beacon that allowed non-Facebook websites to include a script that would send user information back to Facebook. A user didn’t have to be logged in to Facebook for their information to be collected from a third-party site, nor were the users even informed it was happening. Imagine making a purchase on Zappo’s and then having it automatically posted to your Facebook wall. Facebook shut down the service in 2009 just before they settled a class action lawsuit over Beacon.
  • News feed: In 2007, Facebook introduced the News feed and Mini feed that published all of a user’s Facebook activity without allowing users to opt-out. Because of user outcry, Facebook implemented privacy controls for the feeds. Then in 2009, they removed those privacy controls. Again after user outcry, they added more privacy controls and “simplified” their privacy settings. Even though they have been “simplified,” I don’t believe that Facebook privacy controls are “simple” and easy to understand.
  • Inability to delete accounts: This one didn’t affect many users, only those trying to delete their accounts so most people don’t remember it. Even when users deactivated their accounts, Facebook kept copies of their information indefinitely. To this day, you have to submit a request to completely delete your account. If you merely deactivate your account, Facebook still keeps all of your information indefinitely.
I could go on and on, but you get my point– Facebook has done a lousy job at protecting user privacy and they have received great criticism about their deceptive practices. All of this should come as no surprise to anyone who keeps up with Facebook-related news because Mark Zuckerberg doesn’t believe in privacy and he insists that our notion of privacy is changing (not for the better). Interestingly enough, while Zuckerberg pushes to make what you share on Facebook public, he does not share much of his own personal life. This contradiction that has led to further outcries including this bounty by Gizmodo for public pictures of Mark that they will then share on their own site.

Because of all this, one can infer that Facebook has had a deliberate disregard for privacy of its users. Now imagine similar privacy bait-and-switches with children – who are less equipped to understand what is happening and to protect themselves from having their information shared with more people than they intended. And while in my original piece I wrote about how I’m not as concerned about a stranger taking advantage of a child on Facebook as I am about other things, such privacy breeches certainly increase the chances that a person with ill intentions will use the information for their own benefit at the expense of the child.

For these reasons, I don’t trust that Facebook has my best interest in mind and I certainly don’t trust that they’ll have the best interest of children under 13 in mind… and neither should you.

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

  • It’s true! There is a way you can access everything you’ve ever posted on Facebook. It’s crazy to think we are okay with our information being so accessible. I couldn’t imagine Facebook letting people younger than 13 on the site. Even the older Facebookers are easily tricked into giving out information that they probably shouldn’t. Think about how much information they could get from a young kid who is more than happy to share everything with the world. While I admit Facebook has been monumental in connecting people, businesses, etc… it is still scary to think how much access they have to our lives through our personal information. Just something to think about.

  • Colleen McCloskey

    thank you for this post.  very informative.

Creative Commons License
Unless otherwise specified, all content on this blog is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.

This site is using the Junco Child-Theme, v2.0.2, on top of
the Parent-Theme Desk Mess Mirrored, v2.0.4, from BuyNowShop.com.